Trade-ins and other exchanges
Since ASU 2017-05, swapping a plant asset with a party that isn't a customer, such as trading it in to a dealer, generally falls under ASC 610-20 rather than ASC 845 (845-10-15-4(k)). ASC 610-20 measures the noncash consideration at fair value, so the full gain or loss is recognized; when the fair value of what is received can't be reasonably estimated, the fair value of the asset given up is used.
For an exchange that stays within ASC 845, the asset received is measured at the fair value of the asset given up (plus any cash paid), unless the fair value of the asset received is more clearly evident, and the gain or loss is recognized in full. The exceptions use the carrying amount of the asset given up instead:
- the exchange lacks commercial substance: the entity's future cash flows are not expected to change significantly because of it;
- it swaps inventory to help either party sell to customers other than the two parties;
- the fair value of neither asset can be measured within reasonable limits.
In an ASC 845 exchange without commercial substance, the party that pays cash recognizes no gain; the party that receives cash recognizes a gain only on the portion of the deal settled in cash. Any indicated loss is recognized. If cash makes up 25% or more of the fair value of the exchange, the whole transaction is monetary and measured at fair value.