Disclosure that supports informed consent
Standard A.5, Disclose and Manage Conflicts of Interest, sets the bar. Five points decide most cases:
- No good-faith excuse. A planner who sincerely believes the advice was in the client's interest still breaches the Standard by skipping disclosure.
- Form. Consent need not be signed. Consent can be inferred when the disclosure was good enough, and spoken disclosure counts, though CFP Board decides how much weight to give it, so careful planners write it down.
- Content. A footnote saying the firm "may receive third-party payments" fails. Ask whether the client could explain back what the conflict is, which arrangement creates it and why it might tilt the advice; if not, there is nothing informed to accept or refuse.
- Harder cases. A bonus for placing clients in the firm's own private real estate fund needs far stronger proof of agreement than an ordinary fund trail. The riskier or more unusual the arrangement, the stronger the proof needed, and doubts about what a disclosure meant count against the planner.
- Timing. Disclosure and consent come before the advice the conflict touches, never after.
Disclosure is half the job. The planner must also adopt and follow business practices that stop conflicts from distorting advice, such as level pay across similar products or a second review of every rollover recommendation.