Troubled debt restructurings: the debtor's side
A restructuring is troubled when a lender gives a borrower in financial difficulty relief it wouldn't normally offer, such as a lower rate, forgiven principal or interest, or accepting assets worth less than the debt. The lender hasn't granted a concession if the debtor's effective borrowing rate on the restructured debt is no lower than the old debt's effective rate just before the restructuring. ASU 2022-02 removed troubled debt restructuring accounting for creditors, but debtors still follow ASC 470-60:
- Settled with assets. The debtor first adjusts the asset to fair value, recognizing a gain or loss on the asset. It then recognizes a gain on restructuring equal to the payable's carrying amount minus the asset's fair value.
- Settled with equity. The shares are recorded at fair value, and the restructuring gain is the payable's carrying amount minus that fair value.
- Terms modified. Compare the payable's carrying amount, including accrued interest, with the total undiscounted payments due under the new terms. If the payments are less, write the payable down to that total and recognize the difference as a gain; afterward every payment reduces the payable and no interest expense is recognized. If the payments are more, recognize no gain and use a new effective rate that equates the future payments with the carrying amount.
Example: a struggling restaurant chain owes 1,200,000 plus 60,000 of accrued interest. Its lender forgives the interest, cuts principal to 1,000,000 and charges 3% for three more years. The new payments total 1,090,000 (1,000,000 + 3 x 30,000), less than the 1,260,000 carrying amount, so the chain recognizes a 170,000 gain and carries the payable at 1,090,000, with no interest expense for the rest of its term.