US GAAP treats possible gains and losses differently: a probable loss is accrued, but a gain contingency usually waits until it is realized. This lesson covers that asymmetry, insurance recoveries, commitments to disclose, unconditional purchase obligations and losses on firm purchase commitments.
Gain contingencies
A gain contingency is an existing situation that may produce a gain once a future event happens. Examples:
- a lawsuit in which the company is the plaintiff;
- a disputed claim for a tax refund;
- an insurance claim for more than the carrying amount of a destroyed asset.
ASC 450-30 says gain contingencies usually aren't reflected in the accounts, because that could recognize income before it is realized. In practice a gain waits until it is realized or realizable: the cash is received, a settlement is agreed or a judgment is final. A favorable verdict that is still under appeal, or a settlement offer not yet accepted, doesn't qualify, however likely it looks.
They are disclosed when material, but the note must not suggest that the gain is more likely than it is. "Counsel expects to recover in full" in a note can mislead; a factual description of the claim and its status is safer. Being "probable and estimable" is not enough to accrue a gain: that test applies to losses.