US GAAP treats possible gains and losses differently: a probable loss is accrued, but a gain contingency usually waits until it is realized. This lesson covers that asymmetry, insurance recoveries, commitments to disclose, unconditional purchase obligations and losses on firm purchase commitments.
Gain contingencies
A gain contingency is an existing situation that may produce a gain once a future event happens. Examples:
- a lawsuit in which the company is the plaintiff;
- a disputed claim for a tax refund;
- an insurance claim for more than the carrying amount of a destroyed asset.
ASC 450-30 says gain contingencies usually aren't reflected in the accounts, because that could recognize income before it is realized. In practice a gain waits until it is realized or realizable: the cash is received, a settlement is agreed or a judgment is final. A favorable verdict that is still under appeal, or a settlement offer not yet accepted, doesn't qualify, however likely it looks.
They are disclosed when material, but the note must not suggest that the gain is more likely than it is. "Counsel expects to recover in full" in a note can mislead; a factual description of the claim and its status is safer. Being "probable and estimable" is not enough to accrue a gain: that test applies to losses.
Insurance recoveries and involuntary conversions
When an insured asset is destroyed, the asset is written off, giving a loss equal to its carrying amount. The insurance proceeds are a separate matter:
- Proceeds received, or settled with the insurer, are recognized in full, and any excess over the carrying amount is a gain, even if the company must spend the money on a replacement. The replacement is a separate purchase recorded at its own cost.
- If the amount won't be settled until a later period, the contingency rules apply. In practice, a recovery that only offsets the loss already recognized is booked when collection is probable, but any amount above that is a gain contingency and waits until it is realized.
Commitments that must be disclosed
ASC 440 requires disclosure of commitments that matter to readers, even though no liability exists yet. Typical ones:
- restrictions in loan agreements, such as limits on dividends, a minimum working capital level or required debt reductions;
- assets pledged as collateral;
- contracts to buy plant or other long-lived assets;
- letters of credit not yet drawn.
Leases, pension plans and dividends in arrears on cumulative preferred stock (ASC 505) have their own disclosure rules.
Unconditional purchase obligations
An unconditional purchase obligation commits the buyer to pay fixed or minimum amounts for goods or services, whether or not it takes delivery. Take-or-pay contracts (a buyer of electricity pays a minimum even if it draws less) and throughput contracts (a grain shipper pays a rail terminal for minimum volumes, shipped or not) are the usual forms. ASC 440 requires disclosure when the obligation:
- was set up as part of financing the facility that will supply the goods or services, or costs related to them (such as carrying costs for the contracted goods);
- has more than one year left to run;
- can't be cancelled, or can be cancelled only in narrow cases: by paying a penalty large enough that continuing looks reasonably assured, with the other party's permission, by signing a replacement agreement between the same parties, or on a remote contingency.
If it is not on the balance sheet, disclose the fixed and determinable portion in total and, if determinable, for each of the next five years; the obligation's nature and term; the nature of any variable components; and the amounts purchased under it in each income statement period. Disclosing the imputed interest needed to reduce the obligation to present value is encouraged, not required. If it is recorded as a liability, disclose its payments for each of the next five years.
Losses on firm purchase commitments
A firm, noncancellable commitment to buy inventory at a fixed price can produce a loss before any goods arrive. If the commitment isn't hedged, the net loss is measured the same way as an inventory loss and recognized when it occurs, not when the goods are received; if material, it is shown separately in the income statement. ASU 2015-11 didn't change this guidance, so the measure follows the inventory rules: net realizable value for most entities, and market for inventory under LIFO or the retail method. There is no loss if firm sales contracts at fixed prices, or other circumstances, protect the amount to be realized from the goods.
Example: a coffee roaster is committed to buy 50,000 pounds of green coffee at 4.20 a pound, with no sales contracts covering it. At year end, replacement cost and net realizable value have both fallen to 3.60 a pound.
- Loss: 50,000 x (4.20 - 3.60) = 30,000.
- Entry: Dr Loss on purchase commitment 30,000 / Cr Liability on purchase commitment 30,000.
When the coffee arrives, the liability reduces the amount charged to inventory, so the coffee is carried at 180,000 (50,000 x 3.60) rather than the 210,000 paid.
On the exam
Expect the asymmetry to be tested directly: a probable, estimable gain is still not recognized. Other traps: deferring an insurance gain because the money will be reinvested; accruing a commitment that is only disclosed; and missing a loss on a firm purchase commitment, or booking one on quantities protected by firm sales contracts.