Weighing the evidence
All positive and negative evidence is weighed, and each piece counts in proportion to how objectively it can be verified. Cumulative losses in recent years are strong negative evidence and make it hard to avoid an allowance. Other negative evidence includes carryforwards that have expired unused before, losses expected in the next few years, carryforward periods too short for the deductions expected, and unresolved circumstances that could hurt profits for years.
Positive evidence that can outweigh it includes a strong earnings record in which the loss was an unusual, one-off event, assets whose value exceeds their tax basis by enough, and signed contracts or a firm sales backlog large enough to use the DTA. A forecast of profits gets less weight than objectively verifiable evidence.
A change in the opening allowance, caused by a change in judgment about future years, generally goes to income tax expense from continuing operations.
Example. A biotech company has a 400,000 operating loss carryforward, a 100,000 DTA at 25%. Existing taxable temporary differences of 160,000 will reverse within the carryforward period, supporting 40,000. Verifiable future taxable income of 120,000 supports another 30,000. The remaining 30,000 is not more likely than not to be realized:
Dr Income tax expense 30,000 / Cr Valuation allowance 30,000.