Sales with a right of return
A right of return is variable consideration, not a separate performance obligation. At the sale, the entity recognizes:
- revenue only for goods it expects to keep sold;
- a refund liability for the consideration it expects to refund;
- a return asset for its right to recover the goods, at their former carrying amount less expected recovery costs and any loss in value, with a matching reduction of cost of sales.
The asset and the refund liability are presented separately, not netted. Swapping one size or color for another at the same price isn't a return. Exchanging a defective item for a working one falls under the warranty guidance.
Example: a cookware maker ships 2,000 sets to retailers at 150 each (300,000), with 60 days to return them. Each set cost 96. From a long history with many similar retailers, it expects 6% (120 sets) back, each costing 4 to restock. It records:
- Dr Receivables 300,000 / Cr Revenue 282,000 / Cr Refund liability 18,000.
- Dr Cost of sales 180,960, Dr Return asset 11,040 / Cr Inventory 192,000. The return asset is 120 x (96 - 4).