Replacement cost and the 80% rule
A replacement cost policy pays the current cost of rebuilding or buying new. An actual cash value policy pays replacement cost minus depreciation, so an old roof or sofa brings far less. Many insurers require the dwelling to be insured for at least 80% of its replacement cost for a partial loss to be paid in full, before the deductible.
If the owner carries less, the claim is cut in proportion:
Payment = (insurance carried / (80% x replacement cost)) x loss, then minus the deductible, and never more than the policy limit.
Policies differ in whether the deductible comes off before or after the fraction, and many pay at least actual cash value; a question must say which.
Worked example: a house would cost $600,000 to rebuild and is insured for $360,000. The requirement is 80% x $600,000 = $480,000. A $40,000 kitchen fire pays ($360,000 / $480,000) x $40,000 = $30,000, minus a $1,000 deductible, or $29,000. Had the owner carried $480,000 or more, the payment would have been $39,000. Rebuilding costs rise, so the limit needs checking every few years.